Arch Manning Is Still the Most Overrated Player in College Football

Date:

Related stories

Why Every Head Coach Needs a Caddie

A caddie never swings the club, but the best...

The Hellebuyck Decision: What the Rangers Passed On

The Rangers had one chance this fall to turn...

Up Close at Gillette: What Packers 45, Patriots 27 Taught Me

Green Bay beat New England 45-27 at Gillette on...

OPINION: Are the Ravens running out of time to save their season?

BALTIMORE — Eight games into the 2026 NFL season,...

Drew Lock Gets Another Opportunity as Seahawks Name Him Starting Quarterback

The Seattle Seahawks are making a quarterback change heading...

Texas is 4-0 and the No. 1 team in the country, but I’m still waiting to see the performance that justifies all the Arch Manning hype.

Saturday against Tennessee was supposed to be another opportunity for Manning to make a statement. A ranked opponent, more than 100,000 fans inside Neyland Stadium and the entire country watching.

Instead, we got another pretty average performance.

Manning completed 14 of 19 passes for 201 yards, zero touchdowns and one interception in Texas’ 20-17 win. He was also sacked six times and finished with minus-1 rushing yard. University of Texas Athletics

Those numbers aren’t terrible. But that’s exactly the point.

For a quarterback who receives this much hype, “not terrible” isn’t good enough. Texas didn’t win because Manning took over the game. Raleek Brown scored both of Texas’ touchdowns, while the Longhorns defense completely terrorized Tennessee with 10 sacks. University of Texas Athletics

And this isn’t just about Tennessee. Through four games, Manning has thrown for 305 yards against Texas State, 195 against Ohio State, 164 against UTSA and now 201 against Tennessee. FootballDB

Where is the dominant performance against a legitimate opponent?

Manning is obviously talented, and Texas might have the best overall roster in college football. But that’s also why we need to stop automatically giving the quarterback all the credit for Texas being undefeated.

Against Tennessee, the Longhorns needed their defense and running game to escape Knoxville. Manning did enough to help Texas win, but there was nothing about that performance that screamed superstar.

Texas might be No. 1. That doesn’t automatically mean Arch Manning is the No. 1 quarterback. Until he starts dominating these big games, I’m still calling him overrated.

Check Out All EasySportz College Football Content Here!

College Football Viewing Guide 

Subscribe

- Never miss a story with notifications

- Gain full access to our premium content

- Browse free from up to 5 devices at once

Latest stories