CHARLOTTE, N.C. — Jeff Gluck, a respected NASCAR journalist with The Athletic, sharply criticized SiriusXM NASCAR Radio hosts Larry McReynolds and Danielle Trotta for their Tuesday remarks on the NASCAR playoff format, which appeared to target Hall of Famer Mark Martin and driver Denny Hamlin. Larry Mac, oh Larry Mac.
Gluck, a prominent voice in NASCAR media since 2007, condemned the hosts’ tone as “condescending and dismissive,” escalating a controversy that has sparked widespread fan backlash on X.
During the “On Track” show, Trotta referenced a driver on NASCAR’s playoff committee pushing for the pre-2004 Winston Cup points system, prompting McReynolds to retort, “I bet it’s a driver that’s not won a championship.” Fans and Gluck interpreted this as a jab at Martin, who never won a title despite 40 Cup wins, or Hamlin, a vocal playoff critic.
They both came off very condescending and dismissive. Mark is a Hall of Famer and one of the most respected drivers of his era. At minimum, they could feign to have a little more respect.” His comments, reflecting his reputation for balanced analysis, amplified the fan outrage.
Gluck’s standing in the NASCAR industry, built through stints at USA Today, SB Nation, and his own Patreon-funded site, lends weight to his critique. Known for his “12 Questions” interviews and fan engagement through tweetups since 2009, Gluck’s perspective resonates with both fans and insiders. His callout underscores the gravity of McReynolds’ misstep, given Martin’s revered status and Hamlin’s influence as a team owner and driver.
The incident has fueled speculation that McReynolds, a former crew chief with 23 Cup wins and a FOX Sports analyst, may need to issue a public apology.
Fans on X echoed Gluck, with one user, @Rene_gadeCowboy, slamming McReynolds’ “disrespectful” tone.
Jeff Gluck and Larry McReynolds, a duo that goes together like peanut butter and jelly.
With NASCAR exploring playoff changes for 2026, the controversy highlights tensions between the sport’s leadership and its fanbase, who largely favor Martin’s push for a full-season points system. McReynolds and Trotta’s apparent alignment with NASCAR’s current format has drawn scrutiny, and Gluck’s pointed critique suggests the hosts’ remarks could have lasting repercussions.
Let’s look back on Eldora last week!
