MIAMI GARDENS, Fla. —
Four teams remain. Four brands, four paths, four very different arguments — all converging on the same truth: this College Football Playoff has become Indiana vs. the rest of the sport.
That’s not a knock on Oregon, Ole Miss or Miami. It’s a reflection of the data, the markets and what the eye test keeps confirming as the semifinals arrive.
Indiana enters as the No. 1 seed and the betting favorite for a reason. The Hoosiers sit atop the Sagarin ratings at 98.06, well clear of the field. Oregon checks in next at 96.53, followed by Miami (92.36) and Ole Miss (88.69). Vegas largely agrees. Futures odds list Indiana at +132 to win it all, ahead of Oregon (+310), Miami (+340) and Ole Miss (+550).
Different math. Same conclusion.
Indiana has separated itself. Everyone else is fighting for positioning — and respect.
The Semifinals, By the Numbers
The markets have drawn clear lines.
- Indiana (-3.5) vs. Oregon in the Peach Bowl
- Miami (-3.5) vs. Ole Miss in the Fiesta Bowl
Hypothetical title spreads only widen the gap. Indiana would be favored -5.5 vs. Miami and -7.5 vs. Ole Miss, while Oregon would be favored modestly over both Miami and Ole Miss.
Translation?
Vegas sees Indiana first, Oregon second, with Miami and Ole Miss tightly packed behind them.
The seeding order tells a slightly different story — Indiana, Oregon, Ole Miss, Miami — while real-time power ratings muddy it further.
And that’s where things get interesting.
Indiana is a consensus No. 1 at 14-0, despite having just an 8% blue-chip ratio, (the total percentage of four and five-star’s on a program’s roster).
Meanwhile, Oregon has a 67% blue-chip ratio, Ole Miss a 40% blue-chip ratio and Miami a 55% blue-chip ratio. What Curt Cignetti is doing in year 2 in Bloomington is unprecedented. What Pete Golding is doing after Lane Kiffin’s departure is just as impressive.
Team-by-Team: The Case and the Counter
1. Indiana (No. 1 seed | Sagarin No. 1 | Title favorite)
Indiana isn’t surviving games — it’s controlling them.
The Hoosiers rank among the nation’s leaders in efficiency on both sides of the ball, and their dominance looks even more impressive when placed in context. According to recruiting industry metrics cited across ESPN platforms, Indiana’s roster features one of the lowest blue-chip ratios among playoff teams, yet it continues to outperform more talented opponents.
That combination — elite results without elite recruiting — is rare. Add consistency, depth and coaching stability, and Indiana looks less like a story and more like a standard.
The Peach Bowl may be competitive. The bigger picture isn’t. Indiana is the clear No. 1 remaining team.
2. Ole Miss (No. 6 seed | Sagarin No. 8 | Red-hot)
Yes, this is higher than the math says. And yes, it’s intentional.
Ole Miss is playing its best football now — and the Sagarin rating doesn’t fully capture that. It includes games from early in the season, quarterback changes, and an era that no longer exists. Since then, the Rebels have looked sharper, more physical and more disciplined.
The résumé matters. Ole Miss owns a neutral-site win over Georgia and has proven it can win away from home against elite defenses. That matters in January.
The path isn’t easy. Miami’s pass rush is a different animal, and perfection may be required. But if Ole Miss plays a clean offensive game and wins situational moments — red zone, third down, late-game kicking — it has a real edge.
Are the Rebels clearly better than Oregon or Miami? No.
Are they capable of beating either? Absolutely.
3. Miami (No. 10 seed | Sagarin No. 5 | The wild card)
Miami’s résumé is quietly outstanding.
Road wins, high-end competition and a playoff victory over a top-tier opponent have reshaped how the Hurricanes are viewed nationally. ESPN metrics consistently rate Miami among the most explosive teams in the field, and its defensive front creates pressure that can change games quickly.
That’s why Miami is favored in the Fiesta Bowl.
The question is consistency. Miami can look unbeatable for stretches — and then allow momentum to swing. Against Ole Miss, those swings matter. Against Indiana or Oregon, they may be fatal.
Still, Miami has earned its place, and it’s closer to No. 2 than many want to admit.
4. Oregon (No. 5 seed | Sagarin No. 2 | The dangerous underdog)
Putting Oregon fourth feels unfair — and it probably is.
The Ducks’ only loss came at home to Indiana, and that result has aged beautifully. Oregon has grown defensively, tightened its rotations and shown it can lock in when the margins shrink.
If Oregon beats Indiana on Friday night, this entire list flips. Period.
But until that signature second win arrives, Oregon sits just behind teams with more defining moments. This isn’t an indictment. It’s a demand for proof — and Oregon has a chance to provide it.
The Ranking (Right Now)
Factoring in Sagarin, Vegas, recent form, résumé and playmaking:
- Indiana
- Ole Miss
- Miami
- Oregon
And let’s be crystal clear: Nos. 2 through 4 are separated by razor-thin margins. Swap them, argue them, debate them — you won’t be wrong.
Indiana, however, stands alone.
The Bigger Picture
This playoff has also confirmed something else: the Big Ten has surpassed the SEC at the very top, at least for now. Indiana and Oregon aren’t just surviving — they’re setting the pace. The SEC remains deep and dangerous, but the center of gravity has shifted.
Friday night in Atlanta might decide the national champion. Or it might just confirm what the numbers already suggest.
Either way, this isn’t chaos. It’s clarity.
Indiana vs. the field. And the field better be ready.
Check Out All EasySportz College Football Content Here!
College Football Viewing Guide
