ATLANTA –
Winners and Losers: College Football Week 6 delivers chaos, collapses, and clarity
College football’s Week 6 was supposed to be a nap — the kind of Saturday when fans mow the lawn, half-watch the noon slate, and wait for something worth tweeting about. Instead, we got meltdowns, miracles, and Miami swagger. Texas broke again, Penn State imploded again, and somehow, Dan Mullen’s UNLV is 5-0.
In a sport built on chaos, Week 6 was a reminder: no one ever really knows what’s going to happen, including the analytics guys with their Sagarin spreadsheets and “postgame win expectancy.” (Yes, I look at both — religiously and love them).
Let’s get to the verdicts.
Winner: Miami is a playoff team and maybe more?
There’s a quiet hum when “The U” wins the right way — swagger, speed, and competence. The Hurricanes stormed into Tallahassee and walked out with what should have been a double-digit win over Florida State, whose “Super Bowl” apparently ended in Week 1.
Carson Beck sliced up the Seminoles with poise, and Mario Cristobal’s team looked physical at every level. This was a statement — not a playoff one, but a “we’re done being a meme” one. Miami looked built, balanced, and mean.
Meanwhile, FSU’s season peaked with that win over Alabama. Mike Norvell’s team hasn’t adapted, hasn’t evolved, and at 3-2, the ‘Noles are out of ACC contention before mid-October. That’s not bad luck — that’s bad football.
Loser: Penn State just went from an inside joke to a national embarrassment
It’s incredible how Penn State keeps finding new ways to make the same mistake. A 4–0 start felt promising. The usual close James Franklin loss to Oregon was kind of expected. Then came UCLA — young, hungry, fast — and the Nittany Lions forgot how to play defense.
Drew Allar looked like he’d rather be auditing a class than running an offense. James Franklin, the eternal optimist, once again found himself at the postgame podium explaining “execution issues.” No, coach, the issue isn’t execution — it’s identity.
Penn State’s program feels like an expensive treadmill: a lot of motion, no progress. The Lions got bullied by a Bruins team that’s finally putting it together, and Franklin’s familiar 10–2 ceiling is suddenly in jeopardy too.
Trips to Columbus to play Ohio State, a home date with a surging Indiana and a pesky game against Nebraska are left. Oh, there’s also that Iowa game too.
Winner: UCLA grows up and finds its form with Nico
Jerry Neuheisel’s reboot is quickly clicking. That win over Penn State wasn’t fluky — it was forceful. The Bruins leaned on offense, tackled well, and looked — dare we say — organized.
In a season where the Big Ten has two real programs and a dozen middleweights, UCLA looked like it belonged, at least on Saturday. If the Bruins can sustain this, they might pick up a few more wins.
Penn State grabs all the headlines from Saturday, but credit to UCLA for finding an identity and playing to Nico’s strengths.
Loser: Texas — broken again
For all the talk about Arch Manning’s arm talent and Steve Sarkisian’s playbook, Texas still can’t handle adversity. The Longhorns’ Week 6 loss was an unmitigated disaster — turnovers, blown assignments, and the same fragile mentality that’s plagued Austin for years.
Texas hasn’t looked good all year. This program has all the talent in the world and the mental toughness of a paper straw.
Sark’s seat isn’t hot, but it’s definitely preheating and a few more losses would really call his resume into question.
You have the money, why aren’t you winning?
Winner: Texas A&M bullies Mississippi State
Say what you want about Mike Elko’s play-calling — it works. The Aggies mauled Mississippi State in a performance that was statistically dominant and physically imposing.
A&M’s front seven is nasty, and the offense has rhythm for the first time in years. Mississippi State, meanwhile, looked like a team in desperate need of a reset.
The Bulldogs couldn’t block, tackle, or score. It was a complete domination — and, the Aggies looked like the team their recruiting rankings promised.
Loser: Maryland and the 20–0 disaster
You could practically hear the sad trombone in College Park. Maryland jumped out to a 20–0 lead and still managed to lose. Again.
This wasn’t about talent — it was about DNA. The Terps fold when pressure arrives. Mike Locksley has made Maryland relevant, but not reliable. Until that changes, this team will remain the most frustrating “almost” in the Big Ten.
You had this game in the bag! A 20-0 lead blown at home? With a quarterback that’s halfway competent? What are we doing?
Ah, Maryland.
Winner: Georgia’s quiet bounce back
After an ugly week, Georgia remembered it’s Georgia. The Bulldogs dropped 35 on Kentucky using a vanilla offense that still looked unstoppable.
Gunner Stockton was sharp, the run game was balanced, and the defense squeezed Kentucky like a boa constrictor. Kirby Smart didn’t reinvent anything — he just reminded everyone that boring, dominant football still wins.
The dynasty isn’t dead. It was just napping.
Now, I know what you’re thinking. Dude, it’s just Kentucky.
And you’d be correct! But… a win is a win.
We’ll find out more on Georgia this weekend on the Plains.
Loser: Diego Pavia and the mouth that backfired
Vanderbilt’s Diego Pavia spent the week talking. Then he spent Saturday throwing picks. Pavia’s confidence is admirable — but when you run your mouth, you’d better back it up.
Instead, Vandy’s offense collapsed, and their “swagger” turned to sloppiness. Some lessons are best learned in film study.
Credit to Pavia and offensive coordinator Tim Beck for getting to this point. But… the ‘Dores lack the talent and depth to go win the SEC and that won’t change until Pavia is playing in the UFL, the Grey Cup or selling insurance.
Winner: BYU covers, barely
Vegas bettors everywhere rejoiced — or screamed — when BYU stuffed West Virginia at the goal line to secure both the win and the cover. It wasn’t pretty, but it was gutsy.
Kalani Sitake’s group isn’t flashy, but it’s efficient. And for a team projected to struggle, the Cougars look like one of the more stable mid-tier programs in the country.
Winner: UNLV and Dan Mullen’s Vegas magic
Let’s talk about the Rebels. They went into a snowstorm at Wyoming — yes, snow in October — and annihilated the Cowboys. UNLV is 5–0 under Dan Mullen, and the offense looks surgical.
The Rebels keep finding ways to win, no matter the conditions. From the desert to the mountains, this team has become one of the sport’s strangest and best stories.
Mullen’s rebuild isn’t just working — it’s thriving.
Keep stacking wins.
Winner: Virginia’s emotional rebound
Last week, Virginia upset Florida State. Most teams crash the week after an emotional win. Instead, the Cavaliers went on the road and beat Louisville.
Tony Elliott’s group has grit, and in a sport that eats coaches alive, it’s refreshing to see a program claw its way back into relevance.
Remember, that loss to NC State was a non-conference game in the crazy world of conference realignment. The Hoo’s are very much alive in the ACC race!
Loser: Wisconsin and Luke Fickell’s identity crisis
Wisconsin football used to mean power runs and play-action grit. Now it’s confused, overthought, and lifeless.
Luke Fickell was supposed to modernize the Badgers. Instead, he’s neutered them. Wisconsin can’t decide if it’s a spread team or a smashmouth team — and right now, it’s neither.
Until the Badgers rediscover who they are, they’ll keep looking like a mid-tier Big Ten afterthought.
This train is stopped in its tracks, with no signs of forward progress anytime soon.
The Final Word
Week 6 reminded us why we love this sport — chaos, comedy, and catharsis. Penn State fell apart, Texas melted down, and UNLV rose from the ashes.
If you watched it all — if you, like me, consumed 12 podcasts, dissected Sagarin ratings, and questioned Vegas lines — you were rewarded with one of the best Saturdays of the season.
College football never fails to humble, humiliate, and occasionally, heal.
And next week? We’ll do it all again.
Check Out All EasySportz College Football Content Here!
College Football Viewing Guide, Week 7!
