TUSCALOOSA, Ala. —
In the new era of college football, one quarterback decision can ripple across two programs, two fan bases and two coaching tenures. Few choices loom larger this offseason than what Alabama quarterback Ty Simpson decides to do next.
Simpson has three realistic paths in front of him — declare for the NFL draft, return to Alabama for another season, or enter the transfer portal, with Tennessee looming as a very real option, as reported by On3’s Chris Low. There is also a fourth, longer-shot route: chasing an NFL-sized NIL deal at a place like Oregon or Miami. Each option carries consequences far beyond Simpson himself, touching the future of Kalen DeBoer’s Alabama reload and Josh Heupel’s quest to keep Tennessee nationally relevant.
This is not just a quarterback decision. It is a fork in the road for two SEC programs trying to define themselves in a sport that no longer waits for anyone.
Scenario 1: Simpson Returns to Alabama
This is the safest option — for both sides.
Simpson, a former Nick Saban recruit, battled through injuries and inconsistency around him this season. Alabama lacked a reliable run game for long stretches, and wide receiver play fluctuated weekly. Still, Simpson steadied the offense enough to guide Alabama to the SEC Championship Game and a College Football Playoff win in DeBoer’s second season.
From a numbers standpoint, Simpson did what was asked. He protected the football, improved his efficiency as the season progressed and showed command of a new system. Alabama leaned more heavily on short and intermediate passing concepts late in the year, a sign of trust in Simpson’s decision-making rather than sheer arm talent.
Another year in Tuscaloosa would give Simpson continuity — the same staff, the same terminology and another offseason to build chemistry. It would also give DeBoer stability at the most important position in sports.
But this option is not without cost. If Simpson stays, Austin Mack almost certainly transfers. More importantly, it puts pressure on five-star freshman Keelon Russell, the crown jewel of the DeBoer–Courtney Morgan recruiting era. Many Alabama fans want Russell now. The question is whether the timing matches the talent.
If DeBoer can guarantee Russell stays while Simpson starts another year, it’s a smart move. If Simpson’s return pushes Russell out the door, it becomes a dangerous gamble — one that could define DeBoer’s tenure far more than a single season’s win total.
Scenario 2: Simpson Transfers to Tennessee
This is the chaos option.
Simpson grew up a Tennessee fan. Josh Heupel runs one of the most quarterback-friendly offenses in college football, a system that consistently ranks near the top nationally in tempo, explosive plays and scoring. Quarterbacks under Heupel put up video-game numbers, but the development for the next level is worth questioning.
From a purely football standpoint, the fit makes sense. Simpson’s arm strength and athleticism would thrive in Knoxville. He could put up career-best numbers and instantly make Tennessee a legitimate SEC contender again.
But the cost would be enormous. Any goodwill Simpson built in Tuscaloosa would vanish the moment he ran through the “T” at Neyland Stadium. More importantly, it would hand Alabama the nightmare scenario: losing a starting quarterback to a rival — and potentially seeing him beat you in Knoxville the very next season.
For Heupel, landing Simpson would be a program-altering win. For DeBoer, it would raise uncomfortable questions about roster management and retention in the NIL era, although it likely keeps Keelon Russell and even Austin Mack in Tuscaloosa.
Scenario 3: Simpson Declares for the NFL Draft
This is the legacy-preserving move.
Simpson is widely viewed by NFL evaluators as a first-round talent based on arm strength, size and mobility. Another year in college could refine his tape, but it also brings injury risk and uncertainty. Declaring now allows him to leave Alabama as a respected figure — a quarterback who helped stabilize the program during transition.
NFL teams value traits, and Simpson has them. ESPN draft analysts have consistently noted his upside and projection at the next level, even if his college résumé lacks gaudy numbers, due to many factors outside his control.
If Simpson goes pro, Alabama turns the page cleanly. DeBoer can hand the keys to Russell without internal tension, reset the depth chart and sell a clear future to recruits and donors.
Sometimes, the cleanest break is the best one.
Scenario 4: The NIL Wild Card (Oregon or Miami)
This is the true long shot — but it cannot be ignored.
In today’s college football economy, elite quarterbacks can command NFL-level NIL deals. Programs like Oregon and Miami have proven willing to spend, and both offer offensive systems designed to showcase quarterbacks.
Simpson could put up numbers, make money and still hear his name called early in the draft. The downside? He becomes a rental. One year, one stop, one chapter — not a home.
The Bigger Picture
This decision isn’t just about where Ty Simpson plays next season. It’s about identity.
Does Kalen DeBoer double down on experience and stability, or does he roll the dice on potential with Keelon Russell? Does Josh Heupel finally land the quarterback who can elevate Tennessee from dangerous to elite? And in an era where loyalty often loses to opportunity, what does “legacy” even mean anymore?
Fans want answers now, even though players technically have until Jan. 16 to declare for the draft. Coaches want clarity even sooner. The transfer portal opened Jan. 2, and NIL budgets for 2026 are already being planned.
Simpson’s choice will shape two programs — and possibly two coaching eras — more than any signing-day headline. Tennessee fans are already in Heupel’s ear about visiting high school recruits in a time of portal transition this week. He lost a lot of the goodwill he built with a home loss to Vanderbilt and a bowl loss to Illinois.
Landing Simpson would instantly gain back trust with the fanbase, but not having a true answer under center for 2026 would begin hot seat whispers for next season. After all, the quick turnaround Curt Cignetti completed in Bloomington has rapidly turned up the clock at other programs.
If the goal is a true home after football, the best bets remain clear: the NFL, or another year in Tuscaloosa. Everything else comes with noise, money and uncertainty.
But in modern college football, certainty is a luxury few can afford. And Ty Simpson holds all the cards.
Check Out All EasySportz College Football Content Here!
College Football Viewing Guide
