COLUMN: Orioles Roll the Dice on Shane Baz, Betting Big on Ace-Level Upside

Orioles trade prospects for rotation help

The Baltimore Orioles reached a point this winter where standing still was no longer an option. After reaching the playoffs in each of the previous two seasons, Baltimore fell short in 2025, a reminder that progress in the American League East is rarely linear. Good was no longer good enough. The response came in the form of a bold, divisional trade for right-handed starter Shane Baz.

Baltimore acquired Baz from the Tampa Bay Rays in exchange for outfielders Slater de Brun and Austin Overn, catcher Caden Bodine, right-handed pitcher Michael Forret, and a Competitive Balance Round A draft pick in 2026. It is a steep price, one that reflects both the scarcity of high-end pitching and the Orioles’ belief that their competitive window remains open.

This is not a trade built on safety. It is built on projection, confidence, and timing.

Baz is 26, an age when many power pitchers begin to translate raw ability into consistent results. His fastball sits in the upper 90s and can touch triple digits. His slider flashes as a true out pitch. His curveball adds depth and disruption. When everything lines up, Baz looks like a front-line starter capable of dominating lineups multiple times through the order.

That version of Baz has appeared often enough to entice, but not long enough to satisfy.

Injuries have interrupted his development and limited his workload, keeping him from building sustained momentum at the major league level. The Rays managed his innings carefully, as they often do, but eventually faced the same decision they have confronted with other talented arms: hold and hope or move and multiply. Tampa Bay chose volume, trusting its system to turn multiple assets into long-term value.

Baltimore chose upside.

The Orioles are no longer operating from a position of accumulation. Years of drafting and development have produced a deep, young core at the major league level. They can score runs. They can defend. They can survive the grind of a season. What they have lacked is a starter with the kind of raw stuff that can change the shape of a postseason series.

Baz gives them a chance at that.

This move reflects a shift in philosophy. Prospects matter, but the Orioles are now willing to convert depth into targeted talent. De Brun, Overn, Bodine, and Forret all carry legitimate ceilings. The draft pick adds even more future value. But none of those pieces addresses the most immediate need for a team trying to get back to October.

Baz does, even with the risk attached.

The Orioles are betting that health, continuity, and opportunity will unlock the next phase of his career. They are betting that a defined role, a strong defensive roster behind him, and the urgency of a team pushing forward will help Baz turn flashes into consistency. They do not need him to become an ace overnight. They need him to trend toward one.

That distinction matters.

Baltimore also gains flexibility. Baz comes with three years of club control, giving the organization time to manage his workload and development without the pressure of an expiring contract. This is not a rental. It is an investment in what Baz can be, not just what he has been.

The risk is obvious. Pitching always carries it. Injuries linger. Performance fluctuates. The Rays may turn those assets into everyday contributors, as they so often do. But the Orioles understand that the alternative carries risk, too. Waiting after a missed postseason can quietly close windows rather than extend them.

This trade signals that Baltimore does not view 2025 as a turning point backward. It views it as a warning. The margin for error in the AL East is thin, and standing pat often means falling behind.

By acquiring Baz, the Orioles chose to bet on talent over certainty, projection over comfort. If Baz reaches his ceiling, the payoff reshapes the rotation and raises the team’s postseason ceiling. If he does not, the cost will be felt, but the intent will remain clear.

The Orioles are done waiting for the perfect moment. They are betting that this one is close enough.

author avatar
James O'Donnell