MANHATTAN — It is absolutely baffling. The New York Rangers — a franchise dripping with history, flush with resources, loaded with talent, and playing in one of the world’s biggest media markets — should not be this bad in 2025-26. Yet here we are. The Broadway Blueshirts entered this season with all guns aimed at redemption after a dominant 2023-24 season, and instead they’re tripping over their own skates in front of their home crowd at Madison Square Garden while the rest of the Metropolitan Division and the Eastern Conference at large surge past them.
The fall from grace
Let’s rewind briefly: in 2023-24 the Rangers captured the Presidents’ Trophy, logged a league-best 55-23-4 record, and made a deep run to the Eastern Conference Final. They looked like the class of the East, poised to end a Cup drought that stretches all the way back to 1994. Enter 2024-25, and boom — 39-36-7, the first time they missed the playoffs since 2021. Enter 2025-26, and the story takes an even darker turn: as of now they sport a home record of 1-6-1 — yes, one win in eight home games — and are somehow better on the road (7-1-1) than in their own building. No team with this kind of roster should be this dysfunctional.
How the strongest in the east are eating your lunch
So what’s going on? While the Rangers are floundering, franchises like the Carolina Hurricanes, New Jersey Devils and Montreal Canadiens are climbing. The Hurricanes and Devils presently sit at the top of the Metro Division with records like 11-4-0 or 11-4-1. Meanwhile the Rangers are floundering at 8-7-2, with a -2 goal differential and glaring home issues. A team that once toyed with the Hurricanes like kryptonite is now being lapped by them in its own division. That’s an identity crisis.
Big spend, big expectations — zero execution
This is not some budget franchise punching above its weight. This is New York: Original Six, full stands, boot-lace media rights, giant payroll, a bandwagon fanbase that expects wins not seasons of “hope.” They’re supposed to be the Yankees of hockey; instead they’re playing like a franchise that’s been mismanaged, misaligned, and mismatched. Remember how they let Henrik Lundqvist fade during his prime, only to see the Cup window close? They spent years leaning on him, and still never got the job done. Now they’re slipping backwards while letting younger talent like K’Andre Miller walk to Carolina and seeing a death star rising next door.
Talent’s still there—but the gears aren’t
Look: this roster has players. Adam Fox is leading the team in points, he’s one of the league’s best defensemen when he’s moving smoothly. Artemi Panarin is still generating assists, still creating chances—but what good is that if you can’t win in your building? Then you have J.T. Miller, who was supposed to be a big part of the “we’ll win now” era, yet his impact this season feels muted, directionless. On top of it all, goaltender Igor Shesterkin can only bail you out so many times when your offense disappears and your home ice is a rubber match nightmare.
Home ice: supposed fortress, actual embarrassment
Open the curtain at Madison Square Garden. It used to be rivaled only by a few sacred venues. Now? The New York Rangers went through a historic drought, becoming the first NHL team to open a season with three straight home shutouts. That’s not on the opponent—it’s on the roster and organization for failing to show up in front of their own crowd. Getting kicked around at home while still managing to have a respectable road record doesn’t make you resilient—it makes you schizophrenic. And when you have a home-record gap like 1-6-1, your “strong road” becomes less impressive and more patchwork.
No cap space. No plan. No identity.
Here’s the kicker: this franchise doesn’t just lack identity—they seem to lack a plan. They’re near the bottom third of the league in available spending. They don’t have the cap flexibility to add the missing piece. That means you’re stuck banking on internal fixes and hope—dangerous when you’re New York. Bandwagoners, casual fans and even fair-weather New England transplants are shifting their allegiance to the Devils or Islanders, because those clubs look like they have direction. Meanwhile the Rangers risk becoming third wheel in their own metro area, behind the Islanders and Devils. That’s the unthinkable in a market like this. The Knicks have sucked for decades, but at least their dysfunction has started to heal. The Rangers? They’re still bleeding momentum.
It’s still early, yes—but alarm bells are ringing
Look, we’re in early November. The season is long. Conferences are wide open. The New York Rangers could turn this around. But when you’re a team built to win now, with no real runway, these kinds of home losses and offensive droughts aren’t minor—they’re structural. If you miss the playoffs in 2025-26, you’re not rebuilding—you’re failing. And in this market, failure wears long after the buzzer. Ask the Buffalo Bills how that feels.
Final word
The New York Rangers should not be this bad. A team with their annual spending, historical fan-base, marquee players and home-city advantage should not be trending toward mediocrity. They should not be letting the Canadiens, Hurricanes and Devils chew up their turf. They should not be giving the lies to their own legacy. They should not be forcing themselves to rip the band-aid before it peels off ugly and oozing. At this rate they’ll remind you more of the Buffalo Bills than a Stanley Cup contender—lots of hype, lots of tears, no finish line crossed.
If you’re a die-hard fan, this isn’t “tune in and hope” anymore—it’s “tune in and worry.” Because the New York Rangers are hemorrhaging identity, losing the narrative in the biggest hockey city in the world, and unless they fix the structure, the coaching, the cap space and the home ice nightmare—they’ll end the season not with banners but with questions. And that’s the real punchline for a franchise that should be competing damn near every year. The New York Rangers aren’t just struggling—they’re unraveling. The only question left: how much damage will the legacy take before they admit they’re not just a bad season away—they’re a full rebuild away.
Check out all EasySportz NHL Content Here
College Football Viewing Guide, Week 8
