NORMAN, Okla. — Oklahoma and Auburn both arrive in Week 4 undefeated, confident and loudly proclaiming they’ve fixed every flaw that haunted them last fall. But let’s be real: one of these fanbases is going to be insufferable on Sunday morning, and the other will be searching for reasons why “next week” is really the turning point. The Sooners (3-0) welcome the Tigers (3-0) to Norman on Saturday at 3:30 p.m. ET on ABC, and while it’s technically just another SEC opener, the subplot is juicier than most.
Former Oklahoma quarterback Jackson Arnold returns to town, except this time he’ll be in Auburn orange, staring across the field at his replacement, John Mateer, who currently leads the Heisman odds and looks more like the answer than Arnold ever did in Norman. Talk about awkward. But this game isn’t just about nostalgia or revenge—it’s about two programs that spent much of the offseason trying to convince the world their head coaches weren’t on hot seats. Hugh Freeze, in year three at Auburn, and Brent Venables, in year four at Oklahoma, have both delivered quick starts that make their athletic directors breathe easier. One of them will leave with even more credibility. The other? Well, let’s just say SEC message boards are undefeated.
Add in the fact that Oklahoma just beat Michigan at home earlier this season and stunned Alabama in Norman last year, while Auburn has already survived a tricky opener at Baylor, and you’ve got yourself a high-stakes chess match between Freeze’s offensive scheming and Venables’ defensive wizardry.
Vegas calls it Sooners (-7) with an over/under of 46.5, suggesting an old-school slugfest. But our model? It’s a little closer, and it sets the stage for a fascinating Saturday afternoon.
Oklahoma Rolling With Mateer
Let’s start with the obvious: Oklahoma found its quarterback. John Mateer comes in from Wazzu and not only replaces Arnold, but erases him from most Sooner fans’ memories. Mateer commands the offense with poise, takes care of the ball, and suddenly makes Oklahoma’s wide receivers look dangerous again. His efficiency has been the difference, and while he’s not perfect, he’s exactly what Venables needed to balance his defensive-minded program.
The Sooners’ defense, which has been Venables’ pride and joy, looks as stingy as it did at Clemson. They shut down Michigan for long stretches and carry themselves like an SEC defense should. That’s a major reason why OU is 3-0 and sitting 15th in the Sagarin ratings (83.71), outperforming preseason expectations.
Auburn and Arnold Return to Norman
Jackson Arnold is no slouch, though. Auburn’s new quarterback has been steady through three games, avoiding the costly mistakes that doomed Payton Thorne a year ago in Jordan-Hare, when OU rallied late to beat the Tigers. Arnold’s skill set fits Freeze’s scheme better, and he’s got enough weapons to make OU’s secondary nervous.
But Auburn’s road reputation in the SEC is… let’s call it “less than stellar.” The Tigers have dropped too many road games to count since the Gus Malzahn years, and their fanbase knows it. The Week 1 win at Baylor quieted some of those nerves, but Norman is not Waco. The Sooner crowd feeds on moments like this, and Arnold will need to manage the chaos quickly to keep Auburn in rhythm.
Sagarin vs. Vegas: The Numbers Game
Let’s put on our math glasses for a moment. Oklahoma checks in at 83.71 in Sagarin, Auburn at 82.39. Subtract the two and you get +1.32 in favor of the Sooners. Add in 5.38 for home field advantage, and Sagarin projects Oklahoma as about a 6.7-point favorite on Saturday, closely aligning with Vegas’ current number.
Vegas, as always, is just a little sharper, sitting at Sooners (-7) with a total of 46.5. That’s essentially a push with the Sagarin model, but it underlines the expectation: a defensive struggle, where every turnover matters. If you’re betting, good luck predicting whether Freeze dials up a late trick play or Venables’ defense simply slams the door.
This game, similar to Auburn vs. Baylor a month ago, could truly go in 10 different directions. We don’t recommend a spread or moneyline wager on this game, but if you insist…
Auburn’s Keys to Victory
- Win the turnover battle. The Tigers flat-out coughed it up last year in this matchup, and it cost them. Arnold has been careful so far, but this is the type of environment where one bad interception can end the day.
- Establish the run early. Freeze’s offense works best when the ground game opens up his passing wrinkles, led by senior running back Damari Alston, who has not seen the field since Baylor, but was a full go at practice this week. Auburn’s backs need to churn out yards to give Arnold breathing room and Alston has been healing up just for this one through a pair of cupcakes. The Woodward Academy product looks to return to form on Saturday, a positive sign for Tigers fans on the Plains.
- Keep it close into the fourth. If Auburn’s in striking distance late, Freeze always has a gadget play ready. It’s SEC football; trickery is practically a birthright.
Oklahoma’s Keys to Victory
- Pressure Arnold. Make him uncomfortable and force him into the same kind of mistakes that doomed him at Oklahoma. Venables’ defense has the personnel to do it and they’ll know his weaknesses.
- Mateer keeps rolling. The Heisman talk isn’t just smoke—Mateer has to play like a top-flight QB for OU to hold serve at home and fend off a pesky Auburn team full of hungry athletes.
- Lean on the crowd. Norman has already delivered in big games, rattling Alabama and Michigan. Auburn hasn’t been tested like this on the road yet in 2025, even with an early challenge at Baylor helping to soften the shock felt on Saturday.
Coaching Duel: Freeze vs. Venables
This game is also a battle of philosophies. Freeze has always been the “offensive guru,” a coach who loves tempo, spacing, and springing one of those deep balls that makes fans gasp. Venables, on the other hand, built his career shutting down those very schemes at Clemson. Saturday will be strength versus strength, with one coach trying to outfox the other in front of a national audience.
Remember last week’s chess matches of Josh Heupel vs. Glenn Schumann and Mike Bobo vs. Tim Banks in this timeslot? Saturday brings another treat our way!
This might as well be a classic SEC on CBS game at this point, with the weekly bangers we are getting. Cue up the music!
The Auburn Family Meets Sooner Swagger
Let’s not kid ourselves: Auburn fans have spent the week talking up “Auburn magic” online like they’re storming into Norman and waltzing out 4-0. Credit them for their passion, but anyone who’s watched the Tigers melt on the road in the SEC, knows skepticism is still warranted.
Oklahoma fans, meanwhile, are enjoying their SEC honeymoon. After last year’s upset over Alabama softening a rough entry, this season’s takedown of Michigan has things humming again. The Sooner faithful finally feel like they belong in Dixie. Both sides have receipts ready if their team wins and the interwebs should be quite entertaining.
What’s at Stake
For Oklahoma, a win keeps their momentum alive and solidifies Mateer’s Heisman campaign, at least for now. Suddenly, the Sooners look like a true SEC contender, despite a daunting schedule ahead.
For Auburn, a win would prove they’ve truly turned the corner under Freeze and erase lingering doubts about their ability to handle tough road games, picking up a pair of wins out west. A loss for either team wouldn’t end the season, but it would reopen questions about whether their coaches are really steering the ship in the right direction and reignite hot seat debates if this one gets ugly.
Final Word: This one shapes up as a defensive battle where every possession feels magnified. Oklahoma has the edge at home, but Auburn has the firepower to keep it close if Arnold doesn’t blink. Our favorite model, Sagarin, has the Sooners by 6.7 (insert Gen-Z joke here), while Vegas lays the full number. Either way, expect bruises, turnovers, and plenty of angry posts from the losing fanbase by Saturday night.
Prediction:
Oklahoma 28, Auburn 24
Over 46.5 (not a lock, but confident)
*If you bet this game, take the over*
Check Out All EasySportz College Football Content Here!
Looking Back on Vandy Football
