NEW YORK — The New York Giants’ quarterback competition is shaping up as a three-way race, with Russell Wilson, Jameis Winston, and rookie Jaxson Dart vying for the starting role in the 2025 season. As training camp approaches, betting odds reflect a tight contest, with Wilson leading as the favorite, followed by Winston and Dart, according to DraftKings Sportsbook. The New York Giants starting QB battle should be fun.
Wilson holds the edge at -800 odds to take the first snap in Week 1. His experience and proven track record make him a strong contender. The 36-year-old veteran, who threw for 2,482 yards and 16 touchdowns with the Pittsburgh Steelers last season, brings leadership and a knack for fourth-quarter comebacks, boasting 32 since 1950, ninth-most among quarterbacks.
Wilson’s ability to manage games and deliver in clutch moments aligns with coach Brian Daboll’s emphasis on efficient quarterback play. A stronger offensive line, bolstered by a healthy Andrew Thomas, could give Wilson the protection he needs to succeed.
Winston, with +600 odds, offers a compelling case as a dark horse. The former No. 1 overall pick has shown flashes of brilliance, with a strong arm and playmaking ability. His familiarity with high-pressure situations and experience as a starter make him a viable option.
Winston’s recent visit to the Giants’ facility suggests the team values his veteran presence, and his ability to stretch the field could complement wide receiver Malik Nabers, who racked up 1,204 yards last season. If Wilson falters or Daboll seeks a more dynamic passing attack, Winston could seize the opportunity.
Dart, the rookie first-round pick from Ole Miss, sits at +1600 odds but carries significant upside. Selected 25th overall after the Giants traded up, Dart threw for 4,279 yards and added 495 rushing yards in college, showcasing dual-threat potential. His youth and athleticism make him an intriguing long-term option. Daboll has praised Dart’s potential, noting his development will be key. While the rookie faces a steep learning curve, a standout performance in camp could push him into the conversation, especially if the Giants prioritize building around a young quarterback.
The Giants’ offense struggled last season, averaging just 16.1 points per game, ranking 31st in the NFL. The team’s decision to move on from Daniel Jones underscores the urgency to find a reliable starter. Wilson’s consistency, Winston’s explosiveness, and Dart’s potential each address different needs.
The team’s brutal 2025 schedule, including matchups against playoff-caliber teams like the Chiefs and Eagles, adds pressure to resolve the battle quickly.
As camp kicks off, all eyes will be on Daboll’s decision. Wilson’s experience makes him the front runner, but Winston’s arm and Dart’s promise ensure the competition remains open. The outcome will shape the Giants’ season and their hopes of climbing out of the NFC East basement.
Who do you think the New York Giants starting QB will be? Let us know in the comments below!
It’s the New York Giants starting QB competition that has the story lines in Jersey.
Tyrann Mathieu retired from the Saints.
The Giants training camp schedule can be found here.
