Quarterbacks are the lifeblood of NFL teams, but not all who took the field have been Tom Brady or Peyton Manning. Some players seemed more skilled at throwing to defenders than their teammates. Let’s explore the infamous QBs whose stumbles on the gridiron make them unforgettable—just maybe not for the reasons they’d prefer.
JaMarcus Russell
In 2007, the Raiders made JaMarcus Russell their top pick and hoped for a franchise savior. Instead, he threw interceptions, lacked energy, and struggled with accuracy. His 31-game career fell far short of the lofty expectations placed on him.
Ryan Leaf
Leaf was the Chargers’ answer to Peyton Manning—on paper. On the field, he was a turnover machine with a temper that rivaled his poor stats. His sideline meltdowns were legendary, and his 14:36 touchdown-to-interception ratio cemented his spot in NFL infamy.
Akili Smith
Cincinnati gambled big on Akili Smith in 1999, and it was a roll of the dice that went off the table. Over four years, Smith managed just five touchdowns against 13 picks. The Bengals could’ve drafted legends like Edgerrin James, but instead, they got Smith fumbling his way into history.
Heath Shuler
Washington saw Shuler as their savior in 1994. What they got was 33 interceptions and a passer rating barely above room temperature. He was benched for a rookie, Gus Frerotte, making fans wonder if they drafted the wrong guy—or maybe the wrong sport.
Tim Couch
Cleveland welcomed Couch as their first draft pick after rejoining the NFL in 1999. Five injury-plagued years later, his 22-37 record and countless sacks made fans question if he ever stood a chance. The Browns needed hope, but Couch delivered chaos.
David Carr
Carr’s career with the Texans felt more like a sack-a-thon than a showcase of skill. He hit the turf 76 times in his rookie year to set a dubious NFL record. Blame the offensive line, blame the pressure, but Carr never found the success a first-overall pick should.
Rick Mirer
When Mirer joined the Seahawks in 1993, there was hope. That hope fizzled as his 76 interceptions overshadowed 50 touchdowns. His rookie season was a rare bright spot, but the light dimmed fast, leaving Seattle searching for answers—and a better QB.
Blaine Gabbert
Gabbert’s time in Jacksonville was a disaster, with a 5-22 record that reflected his struggles. Under pressure, he seemed lost, scrambling desperately while his stats spiraled, which left fans frustrated and hoping for something better.
Brady Quinn
Quinn was a first-rounder with all the college hype, but his NFL stint sputtered out like a bad engine. A 4-16 record and a passer rating of 64 left Browns fans reminiscing about quarterbacks who were mediocre rather than terrible.
Christian Ponder
Ponder’s time in Minnesota was marked by missed chances and hesitation. With a career completion rate under 60% and a passer rating in the 70s, his performance left critics constantly “pondering” what could’ve been.
Brandon Weeden
With a baseball background, Weeden’s arm wasn’t quite right for football in Cleveland. Despite being 28 and experienced, his 5-15 record as a rookie only made the Browns’ quarterback carousel spin faster and faster.
Matt Leinart
Leinart’s college stardom didn’t translate to the NFL. He had all the tools, but his inability to stay healthy or productive kept him sidelined. Cardinals fans quickly moved on after they realized that his potential was just a mirage.
Joey Harrington
Although Detroit drafted Harrington as their savior in 2002, his 26-50 record crushed that dream. His knack for costly interceptions earned him the nickname “Joey Blueskies” for his frequent high throws into the secondary.
Mark Sanchez
Sanchez’s back-to-back AFC Championship appearances were overshadowed by a costly fumble. As turnovers and benchings piled up, his career slowly slipped from early success into frustration, defining his legacy in a way no one expected.
Josh Freeman
From a promising start in Tampa Bay, Freeman’s career was undone by inconsistency and poor decision-making. A disastrous stint with the Vikings sealed his fate, which turned him into a story of what could have been.
Bobby Hoying
Hoying’s brief starting tenure with the Eagles in the late ’90s was what everyone was talking about—for all the wrong reasons. He failed to throw a single touchdown in 1998, making his starting record a dismal chapter for Philly fans.
David Klingler
Klingler stepped into the NFL as a supposed savior for the Bengals but quickly became their burden. His 4-20 record and inability to score consistently made him a draft-day regret that lingered for years.
Art Schlichter
Schlichter’s NFL career was marred by both gambling troubles and poor play. With an unflattering 0-6 record as a starter for the Colts, he never truly found his rhythm, often spending more time on the sidelines than in the game.
Deshone Kizer
Kizer had the unenviable task of leading the 2017 Browns—finishing with a winless record. His 11 touchdowns against 22 interceptions felt more like a comedy of errors than a quarterback’s journey to greatness.
Nathan Peterman
Five interceptions in a single half of football set a bar so low that few could trip over it. Peterman’s NFL debut was one for the history books in all the worst ways. Somehow, he managed to become the punchline of quarterback jokes league-wide.
20 of the NFL’s Worst Starting Quarter Backs