The NFL is a high-stakes game where a coach’s brilliance can dramatically shift a season’s outcome. With a mix of seasoned strategists and rising stars leading teams, the 2024 season is shaping up to be a thrilling battle of wits. Considering their play-calling, leadership, and overall impact, we’ve ranked the current crop of NFL head coaches. Let’s see where your favorite coach stacks up.
15. Brian Daboll, New York Giants
The Giants’ struggles can’t solely be blamed on Brian Daboll’s coaching. Injuries to key players like Daniel Jones derailed the season, but the real challenge lies in bolstering offensive talent. Losing Saquon Barkley was also a setback, but the addition of Malik Nabers, approved by Daboll offers hope for a brighter future and a potential playoff return.
14. Kevin Stefanski, Cleveland Browns
While the team had a season filled with challenges, the Browns defied expectations under Kevin Stefanski’s leadership, winning 11 games—their highest total since 1994. Stefanski, a two-time Coach of the Year winner, navigated a tumultuous year that included five different starting quarterbacks and the early loss of Nick Chubb, ultimately guiding the team to an impressive finish.
13. Sean McDermott, Buffalo Bills
Under his leadership, the Buffalos have thrived, winning at least ten games annually since 2019 and securing four straight AFC East titles. However, while they dominated following Tom Brady’s exit, they’ve faced frustrating playoff exits, notably last year with home-field advantage over the Chiefs. Still, the Buffalos cannot be dismissed from the playoff race, partly thanks to Sean’s leadership.
12. DeMeco Ryans, Houston Texans
The Texans’ first season under new leadership was nothing short of remarkable. After years of struggling, Ryans transformed the team’s culture and performance, winning 11 out of 16 games after a tough 0-2 start. Despite concerns about the talent gap, the defense excelled, driven by Ryans’ vision, while C.J. Stroud’s brilliance ignited the offense.
11. Zac Taylor, Cincinnati Bengals
Despite Joe Burrow’s injury for much of the season, Zac Taylor resiliently led the Bengals. Taylor nearly guided the team to the playoffs, leveraging Jake Browning effectively as a backup. With Burrow healthy next season, the Bengals will be strong contenders, particularly against the Kansas City Chiefs.
10. Matt LaFleur, Green Bay Packers
Matt LaFleur’s 2023 season stands out despite losing Aaron Rodgers. He led the Packers through a transition year and led them to the playoffs. Green Bay unexpectedly won the No. 2 seed Cowboys in the Wild Card round and came close to the NFC title game, with Jordan Love thriving under his guidance.
9. Jim Harbaugh, Los Angeles Chargers
Returning to the NFL after a decade, Jim Harbaugh is set to reestablish himself as a premier coach. Formerly guiding the 49ers to three straight NFC Championship games and a Super Bowl loss to his brother’s Ravens, Harbaugh now aims to elevate the Chargers, leveraging his successful Michigan tenure and leadership skills.
8. Sean Payton, Denver Broncos
The Broncos endured a rocky start under Sean Payton, including a humiliating loss. However, they impressively rebounded with a five-game winning streak against playoff contenders. While Russell Wilson showed improvement, the team now looks to Payton to develop rookie QB Bo Nix, promising an exciting future.
7. Mike McDaniel, Miami Dolphins
Miami Dolphins fans should be excited about the Mike McDaniel era. The former San Francisco offensive coordinator has revolutionized the team with innovative strategies, highlighting players like Raheem Mostert and Devon Achane. Although injuries hampered their season, McDaniel is clearly guiding the Dolphins in the right direction.
6. Mike Tomlin, Pittsburgh Steelers
In his 17 years at the helm in Pittsburgh, Tomlin has impressively avoided a losing record each season. Even with fluctuating quarterback performance over the past two years, his teams have remained competitive week after week. While the Steelers might not always be AFC top contenders, Tomlin’s unwavering leadership and ability to keep his squad prepared is remarkable.
5. Dan Campbell, Detroit Lions
Dan Campbell resurrected the Detroit Lions in just three seasons. From a dismal three-win debut, he guided the team to nine wins in Year Two and a division title with twelve victories the following year. Known for his aggressive playcalling, Campbell’s bold coaching has transformed the Lions from NFL doormats to NFC contenders.
4. John Harbaugh, Baltimore Ravens
As a Super Bowl champion, Harbaugh (Jim Harbaugh’s brother) is an elite coach. Baltimore has shown great potential in recent playoff runs, and their promising start in 2023 highlighted their capabilities. Although they faced a tough challenge in the AFC Championship against the Chiefs, Harbaugh’s leadership continues to inspire high expectations.
3. Kyle Shanahan, San Francisco 49ers
Famous for his innovative offensive strategies, Shanahan has yet to win a Super Bowl. His first opportunity with the Falcons ended in a dramatic loss, and despite the 49ers’ talented roster, he has faltered in two Super Bowl attempts. Shanahan’s offensive brilliance is clear—will his third attempt bring success?
2. Sean McVay, Los Angeles Rams
Heading into 2023, the Rams were dismissed due to an aging roster. However, McVay’s ingenuity led to a top-ranked offense, surprising many with a postseason appearance. His talent for finding gems like Kyren Williams and Puka Nacua shone through, and with defensive upgrades, the Rams could emerge as a strong NFC contender.
1. Andy Reid, Kansas City Chiefs
The Chiefs remain a Super Bowl contender with Patrick Mahomes on the team. Yet, they can’t do it without the brilliant Andy Reid. Despite being in his mid-60s, Reid continues to prove his worth with seven seasons of at least ten wins and a Super Bowl victory. A third title would further solidify his legendary coaching legacy.
Top 15 NFL Head Coaches Ranked